Wednesday, August 18, 2010
Talmudic Icons
Not much later, at about the time the Dura Synagogue came into being, the Palestinian Talmud records the grudging recognition of Jewish art ( Abodah Zarah 48d ): “In the days of Rabbi Jochanan, men began to paint pictures on the walls, and he did not hinder them”, and “In the days of Rabbi Abun, men began to make designs of mosaics and he did not hinder them.” ( Abodah Zarah 42b ). To the above passages, we add still another, Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Leviticus 26:1. This Aramaic translation first paraphrases the prohibition against making idols and graven images and such figures in stone as men bow down to. Then the text makes an exception: “But a stone column carved with images and likeness you may make upon the premises of your sanctuaries, but not to worship them.” At last we hear the correct application of the second commandment.
Jacob Milgrom, “The Dura Synagogue and Visual Midrash,”
Scriptures for the Modern World, ed. Paul R. Cheesman and C. Wilfred Griggs
(Provo, UT: Religious Studies Center, Brigham Young University, 1984), 29–60.
Scriptures for the Modern World, ed. Paul R. Cheesman and C. Wilfred Griggs
(Provo, UT: Religious Studies Center, Brigham Young University, 1984), 29–60.
Labels:
A Defense of the Holy Icons,
Icons,
Judaism,
Lvka,
Protestantism
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Links
FUNDAMENTAL LINKS
POPULAR POSTS
-
From the book The Person in the Orthodox Tradition by Metropolitan of Nafpaktos Hierotheos, and translated by Esther Williams "&q...
-
Eventhough the Council of Carthage was a local North African Council it became Universal when the decrees were added to the 6th ecumenical ...
-
Metropolitan Kallistos Ware talks about Saint Gregory Palamas , Apophatic Theology, and the Essence vs. Energies Distinction Apophatic The...
-
Audio Confronting the Doctrine of Sola Scriptura , by Fr. Jon Braun. (This one is mostly about what some Protestants call Solo Scriptura , o...
-
From Scripture: Romans 8:29 For those God foreknew he also predestined to be conformed to the likeness of his Son, that he might be the f...
TOPICS
- A Biblical Defence of Orthodoxy (13)
- A Defense of the Holy Icons (10)
- Abortion (3)
- About Us (14)
- Absolute Divine Simplicity (2)
- Addiction - Idolatry - Spiritual Struggle (37)
- Apocrypha (4)
- apologetics (3)
- Apophatic Theology (1)
- Articles (6)
- Asceticism (1)
- Atheism (10)
- Atonement (23)
- Audio (6)
- Books (19)
- Calvinism (51)
- Canon of Scripture (8)
- Christmas Carols (4)
- Christology (28)
- Church Calendar (104)
- Church Fathers (66)
- Church History (26)
- Cyrillian Chalcedonianism (1)
- David (4)
- Debates (8)
- Double Standard (40)
- Eastern Orthodoxy NOT Refuted (6)
- Ecclesiology (5)
- Eschatology (6)
- Essence and Energies (2)
- Eucharist (10)
- Exegesis (18)
- Fasting (80)
- Fathers and Sola Scriptura (13)
- Fathers on Free Will (6)
- Fathers on the Eucharist (3)
- Feminism (6)
- Filoque (1)
- Hell (9)
- Heretical Christology (4)
- Heretical Triadology (1)
- Holy Spirit (1)
- Homosexuality (2)
- hypostasis (7)
- Icons (19)
- Is Eastern Orthodoxy Christian? (2)
- Islam (13)
- Jehovah's Witnesses (6)
- jnorm (12)
- Judaism (14)
- Justification (19)
- Kabane52 (8)
- Lvka (197)
- Martyrdom (17)
- Mary (8)
- Miscellaneous (131)
- Monothelitism (1)
- Morality (33)
- Mormonism (1)
- Myths (3)
- Old Calendarism (3)
- Original Sin (2)
- Orthodox (9)
- Pages (9)
- Patristics (1)
- Philosophy and Politics (12)
- Prayer (11)
- Prayers to the Saints (2)
- Predestination (5)
- Prosperity Gospel (4)
- Protestantism (206)
- quotes (1)
- Rebuttals (10)
- Relics (1)
- Resources (28)
- Roman Catholicism (20)
- Romans (3)
- Romans Chapter 9 (5)
- Sacraments (19)
- Schismatics (4)
- Scripture (2)
- Sola Fidea (1)
- Sola Scriptura (25)
- Soteriology (1)
- Theotokos (3)
- Tradition (8)
- Triadology (8)
- Video Resources (14)
- Videos (30)
FOLLOWERS
THUS SAITH THE LORD
Pages
MONTHLY ARCHIVE
-
▼
2010
(191)
-
▼
August
(37)
- The Fallacy Of Believing That Christ Died On The C...
- Why We Baptize Infants Of Believing Parents
- Why "Activists" Will Lose Their Souls, Even Though...
- A Rose, By Any Other Name...
- Works Righteousness
- Saint Augustine In His Middle Years
- A Short Exposition of Romans Chapter 9
- The Flow of Election in Romans Chapter 9
- The Council of Carthage and the Doctrine of Origin...
- Every Thing You Always Wanted To Know About Me * B...
- The Fool Hath Said In His Heart: "There Is No Pope !"
- Why the Filioque is False
- Icon-ceivable!
- About The Information Available Here On This Site
- Talmudic Icons
- Unconditional Election
- Exegeting Ephesians 2:8-10
- More Unanswered Questions
- Ephesians 2:8 and "The Gift of God"
- The Orthodox Christian Doctrine of Salvation
- John 3:16 And The Word "World"
- Apostolic Succession 101
- When Did Rabbinical Jews "Officially" Reject the D...
- The Syrian Influence on Iconography
- The Book of Wisdom & Early Christians
- The Jewish Talmud Calls the Book of Sirach Scripture
- New Patron Saint And Blog-Motto
- Acts 10 and Chrismation
- Transfiguration Day
- What Do We Mean By Tradition?
- The Problem of Heresy for Protestantism
- The Eucharist as Sacrifice
- Expiation vs Propitiation
- A Short Critique of "Liberation Theology"
- What Dinosaur Fossils And Ancient Synagogue Painti...
- The Protestant Scriptural Dilemma in 6 Easy Steps
- Saint Hippolytus Changed His Mind About Chiliasm
-
▼
August
(37)
2 comments:
Excellent! Fr. Stephen Bighams "Early Christian Attitudes Toward Images" examines the same information at length; Protestant iconoclasm has zero historical basis.
Awesome, awesome! You guys are bringing out some great stuff. Where will iconoclasts go to find refuge?
Old Testament Israel? OUT!
The ancient Church? OUT!
Talmudic/Rabbinic Judaism? OUT!
Martin Luther? OUT!
The only place that possibly remains to take up refuge under is an inflated and self-willed ego...
Thank you gentleman!!